Why we should listen to Jane Austen in the age of Tinder
Don't dismiss Austen's novels as satires of another era. From how her characters 'game' the system to their desire to marry for love, her plots, and advice, remain highly useful today.
By Hephzibah Anderson
Jane Austen had good reason to be so enamoured of the marriage plot. Put plainly, marriage was a colossally big deal in early 19th-Century England – considerably more so than it is for many of us today. With divorce almost impossible, a hasty choice of spouse came with decades of leisure at which to repent. Pity poor Mr Bennet in Pride and Prejudice, for instance; so "captivated by youth and beauty" was he that he was blinded to his future wife's altogether less comely character. Five daughters on, he is stuck with her inane chatter across the breakfast table.
For a woman, accepting the wrong proposal (and it always was a case of accepting, rather than initiating) could prove still more devastating. Forbidden from inheriting and faced with towering obstacles if they sought to earn their own living, middle-class Regency women – even those blessed with large dowries – had to hand control of their financial, social and emotional wellbeing over to their husbands. They had few legal rights as singletons. But once married, in the eyes of the law they ceased to exist altogether, becoming possessions instead of individuals. A spinster, meanwhile, was forever dependent upon the goodwill of (male) relatives.
If debutantes devoted themselves to husband-hunting to the exclusion of all else, it was because this was their one shot at steering their own destinies. To quote Mary Crawford in Mansfield Park, marriage was "a manoeuvring business".
But while we may shake our heads over women's disenfranchisement and marvel at the quaintness of a world in which the most physical a courtship gets is when a gentleman takes a lady's hand on the dance floor – with a layer of glove to separate their sweaty palms – similarities between dating then and now abound. The rules may be less explicitly stated today. Still, the pursuit of a mate in the age of the television show Love Island remains riven by many of the same snobberies, cynicism and prejudices that circulated at the Netherfield Ball.
For one, women marry young in Austen's novels. Of the Bennet sisters, Lydia weds at 16 and Mrs Bennet talks of Jane's power to ensnare an eligible gaze at just 15. Catherine Morland, along with Sense and Sensibility's Dashwood sisters and Mansfield Park's Fanny Price, are all engaged as teenagers. In Pride and Prejudice, Charlotte Lucas is widely considered over-the-hill at 27.
The notion that a woman's allure carries an expiration date has proven tough to shake. Today, it's more likely to be at the age of 37 – but the cliff-edge remains, buttressed by declining fertility if nothing else. While Emma Woodhouse and Marianne Dashwood both marry men almost two decades their senior, in all of Austen's novels, there's just one wedding at which the bride is older than the groom – Charlotte Lucas, who has a scant two years on Mr Collins. (This despite the fact that, as UCL's Professor John Mullan has observed, three of Austen's own brothers married older women.)
There was also a very public aspect to the dating game. An unmarried couple would never have been allowed to spend time together unchaperoned. Even writing to someone of the opposite sex was frowned upon unless you happened to be engaged.
Today, in our own social-media-strutting, reality-TV era, we willingly surrender our right to conduct what passes for courtship in private. Digital dating encourages us to advertise our wares and trumpet our ideal match's attributes. And if the obsession with financial assets that fuelled so much banter in Regency drawing rooms seemed to commodify men and women, it has nothing on the conveyor belt of faces (and hopes and desires) that we're encouraged to swipe our way through on our phones.
Similarly, no amount of interference from the likes of Emma's eponymous heroine can have 'gamified' the search for love to the extent of apps like Coffee Meets Bagel.
These apps also reinforce another aspect of dating that would have been all too familiar to Austen. Increasingly, their algorithms stratify users to ensure that they only view prospective dates in their own 'tier'. Bank balances and acreage may no longer be overt factors in determining placement – but popularity and attractiveness are just as elitist as markers.
Meanwhile, traditional snobbery lives on. Aside from their servants, Austen's characters rarely met folk from lowlier sections of society, and the Marriage Act of 1753 guarded against marrying beyond one's rank. Elizabeth Bennet succeeds in 'marrying up' a notch when she weds Darcy, but that's about as radical as cross-class marriages come.
Today, for all that we live in a nominally egalitarian society, how many people marry outside of their socioeconomic brackets? To the extent that it does happen, it's a one-way street: a man will marry up but a woman is reluctant to 'date down'. One of the most frequently cited reasons for the growing number of single college-educated women is that they outnumber male graduates and are unwilling to consider mates with an inferior academic track record.
We also should consider those who've simply had enough of dating. How much easier is it to be single nowadays than in Austen's time?
Here in the West, the single woman's lot is certainly vastly improved. She may inherit property and follow almost any career path she chooses. Yet the tyranny of two persists. As Kate Bolicks's 2015 book Spinster so articulately pronounced, society still looks suspiciously on the single woman. It is presumed – as it so famously was of Mr Darcy – that you want and indeed need to be married. Single men and women both experience prejudice when it comes to everything from booking a holiday to filing their tax return.
So while the rules have changed, the game essentially remains the same. If this leaves you feeling downcast, remember that ultimately, Austen advocates marrying for love. It's the move that all her novels champion. It also reinforces what Austen-lovers have always known: you can't go wrong by asking yourself "What would Lizzie Bennet do?"
If you're still feeling sceptical, consider the case of Devoney Looser, author of The Making of Jane Austen. Looser's own love life was directly shaped by Austen when she met her husband of 20 years over an argument about Mansfield Park. "I think you can learn a great deal about a date from his or her views on Austen's fiction. It's a kind of window onto each other's values or desires, allowing you to grasp your date's own character through his/her sense of Austen's characters and scenes," she says.
"But even if your date hasn't read Austen, her plots can be useful in contemporary courtship situations. Austen's heroines don't settle. They don't let parents dictate their choice of partner. They don't let false, self-interested friends influence their romantic choices. Her heroes unfailingly appreciate women with strength of mind or strength of character. Austen's hero-heroine couples are just about the closest thing you'll find to relationships of equals in the literature of her day. Marriage may look like something far different in the 21st Century than it did in the 18th — and thank goodness for that — but the sorts of paths more likely to lead to greater romantic happiness still share a great deal with Austen's fictional vision."
Plus, read at a safe distance of several centuries, there's an added dimension to the delight we find in the pages of Austen's novels: comfort. Like all sports, husband-hunting came with rules. Ask anyone who's been 'ghosted' by their latest Tinder fling and they're likely to confide that there is something just a bit reassuring in the notion of rules writ so clearly.
Proposed crippling countrywide strike TO SAVE ECONOMY, ASSETS, NATURAL RESOURCES– D.J. RAJAKARUNA
- Doha visa waiver for 80 countries Lankan job market under threat 3224
- AG warns against delaying Audit Bill Phobia on surcharge powers 2555
- Report on mayhem at FTZ President’s Office opts to remain silent 2735
- Market enjoys $ 88M NFIs 2559
- Political controversies laid to rest Stock Market makes gains 2562
- Implementation of sticker proposal on Liquor Delay costs Govt Rs 40B 2724
- CBK secretly invited Norway Only two people in Colombo knew when I first met Prabhakaran – Solheim 2586
- Harmony needed for religious freedom – Minister 3005
- CMC property taxes 3008
- Proposed tax on EPF, ETF ICEU seeks urgent meeting with Minister 3012
- Car plunges into river Two dead, three critically injured 3138
- Arson attack on schoolgirl’s house Minister promises new home 3010
- Australian gender advocate in Lanka Broderick to meet business, public leaders 2970
- Fire at Weligama textile store 2984
- Protest planned on Matale A9 Road Compensation demand for lost property 2974
- Rs 128,250,000 spent on survey Samurdhi union demands reimbursement 3069
- NEC to boost economy – President Shot in the arm for agriculture sector 2966
- Driver who killed 13 in Barcelona rampage Spanish police in manhunt 2948
- NLB, DLB back with Finance Ministry 2945
- Govt. has failed says Sampanthan Complains in letter to UNSG 2958
- New LG Draft Bill in Parliament on 24 August 2946
- Travis Sinniah appointed Navy Chief Holder of highest combat medal 3051
- Solution to ethnic issue New Constitution the only way – Mano 2945
- 18-year sentence sought for Lankan Convicted of human smuggling 2949
- SIS man on the mat Nabbed with gold at BIA 2950
- Mixed reaction to ‘bus priority lane’ 2021
- Why jo remained in CA 2093
- Bribery and corruption pervasive malaise in Sri Lanka 3281
- Schoolboy publisher Notching up half a century in business 2963
- Spirits Nether world inhabitants visiting us 2959
- Sri Lanka Vs India 1st ODI Sri Lanka out to change fortunes 1770
- Never Thought I’ll be SL captain – Tharanga 1819
- Anika clinches fifth tennis crown 1764
- ‘Singer Cup’ U-17 Division II Cricket St. Peter’s win by two wickets 1753
- X Pro Academic U-15 team here 1758
- ‘Singer Cup’ U-17 Division II Cricket St. Sebastian meet Thurstan’s in semis today 1758
- Cook and Anderson pile on agony for West Indies 1747
- All Blacks hit highs in 54-34 win over Wallabies 1750
- Sri Lanka lose opening match 1751
- Seven countries compete 2963
- The day JRJ survived an assassination attempt in Parliament Recollection of a miraculous survival! 1938
- People in a dilemma To feed or not to feed starving animals 1922
- Bid to save jumbos from extinction 1929
- Manhandling a lift operator Is the IGP above the Law? 1942
- Political commentary What’s next? Who’s next? 3834
- Students won’t give up till demands met – Lahiru 1623
- Referendum needed to postpone polls – Deshapriya 1678
- Proposed crippling countrywide strike TO SAVE ECONOMY, ASSETS, NATURAL RESOURCES– D.J. RAJAKARUNA 2825
- No taxes on EPF withdrawals– John Seneviratne 3444
- Zero support for Justice Minister within UNP – Ajith P. Perera 3498
- New programme to uplift SMEs soon 1535
- Govt urges CEB, ‘Obey Orders’ 1541
- Banks and insurance companies should collaborate 1540
- Duty waiver will hit BOP, drain forex – Senior Economist 1700
- Infosys CEO Vishal Sikka resigns 1542
- CBSL to resume talks with PayPal & Stripe 1708
- Pan Asian Power acquires Kotmale Oya Power Two 1524
- HNB records Rs 13.4 B in PBT 1521
- Visits to UK rise amid fall in pound 1526
- Mobitel unveils next tech revolution with ‘X Station’ 1537
- A time of gifts Staying on 1572
- Manuka honey:The superbug killer 2515
- A time of gifts Trying to settle down 2270
- Chithral releases his latest song 1576
- Florals: A Fashion Favourite 1572
- Be a lioness not a lamb 1054
- Places to visit in Kandy 1402
- Dhothalu Oya Sandaraja Forest amidst tea estates 1529
- prelate who promoted Buddhist studies in British era 1534
- Principles underlying planetary combinations Understanding and Interpreting their results 1534
- CAUSE OF DEATH- 2 1522
- How to identify 22nd Derkanadhipati 1517
- Shadow planets transit new Houses 1519
- Cinema of Attraction 1790
- The global and local in Hong Kong cinema 1851
- Pakistani Cinema Had Its Own Way of Looking at Partition Too 1539
- Locarno: Sri Lanka’s Sky Entertainers Presents Lineup at Open Doors Lab 1646
- Fitting Social critique 2109
- Collection of critical essays 1521
- Ven. Olande Anada Thero Encountering Buddhism 1521
- De Lanerolle brothers redefined SL music scene 1515
- Knowledge on the go 894
- Anxiety: the 21st century pandemic 1045
- Prawn farming – a delicious destruction 912
- When you hit rock bottom 936
- Electronic waste – a looming threat 897
- The humble roti revamped 901
- A knockout victory 892
- Sharing a bit of Italian history 908
- Magic pills and cute emojis 905
- A decade of victories 894
- Promising and creepy 896
- A choral treat 889